The actual lesson went as it would with the thoughts of who I was questioning in mind... great with some and others not playing along with me. My first and second class seem to enjoy it the most, but by the time Thursday came around, they were not on board. I had them standing in a circle (yeah truth circle) to see each other, and I also said that I would be joining in the questioning as well- Chapter 5 made a point that didn't stick enough with me- But then last week Karen reminded me that we have to show our students that we are willing to be vulnerable with them (Thank you Karen J ). As I prompted the questions I noticed exactly what every teacher hopes for- many started looking around the room and connecting with others based on what they had in common. I also noticed the typically eye rolling at some questions or at their peers responses. But if I was going to build this sense of community for our Hero unit- we would need to see how each other feel. Here are my questions and the observations I took- as well as a few added questions that came as we worked:
1. How many of you enjoy school? As the week went on, less hands were raised
(Map testing)
2. How many of you enjoy spending
time with your friends? All hands went up
on this one and lots of giggles.
3. New
Question- How many of you like getting to meet new people? About 50% of the
class seemed to like this idea.
4. How many of you think school
is hard? Some hands went up and this is
the one where they were looking around to see others and judging one another as
they answered.
5. How many of you think MAP
testing is hard? Again with their
judgments- only about 1/3 of the class would raise their hands- but many of
them were commenting that “it’s not hard, I just don’t like it”
6. New
Question- We did the thumb gage on this one. Show me by thumbs- Up you like MAP
Testing (1 or 2 in each class). Thumbs to the middle- MAP testing is okay (6-8
in the beginning of the week). Thumbs down- you don’t like MAP testing (this
portion got bigger as the week went on).
7. How many of you are worried
about middle school next year? Most
raised their hand for this one- and those who didn’t simply showed the answer
on their face and their peers recognized they were all a little nervous.
8. How many of you want to take
art/choir/band/drama next year? J Almost all raised their hands- many smiled at me and said they were
taking art!
9. How many of you like living in
our community of Blue Springs? Almost all
10. How many of you like the
neighborhood you live in? Only 1-2 didn’t
raise their hands for this one and many were connecting with those who lived in
their neighborhood.
11. How many of you can think of
something you would like to change about Blue Springs? This question I allowed to settle- asked the kids not to answer until I
said to. Many did raise their hands-but with comments like we need a candy
store or toy store.
12. How many of you think there
are problems in Blue Springs? I also made
them wait to answer this one- and I posed this thought after day 1 “Not just we
don’t have the store I want, but for example we don’t have a cross walk for me
to safely walk across 7 hwy (small town hwy but we don’t have this for our
neighborhood)-As they thought(aloud to help them generate ideas) more heads
were nodding- when we took our vote about 80% raised their hands.
13. How many of you think that YOU
could help with solutions to make your community better? This one was sad (and why I wanted to develop this unit to begin with)Only
about 50-60% of each class thought they could do something to help.
14. How many of you think would
like to help your community to be a better place? Almost all hands went up for this- and immediately they started talking
about ways to make some of those changes- usually involving money.
15. How many of you can think of a
hero? All raised their hands- most were
saying names of movie heroes.
16. How many of you can think of a
hero from Blue Springs? They had to think
about this one and only about 30% were raising their hands.
Overall it went pretty well, but I wonder what it would have
been like if I could have done this: Give each student a clicker and they get
to anonymously vote and their responses would show on the board immediately in
the form of a graph. Would this have allowed them to be more honest sometimes? Of
would this have taken away the connections and empathy that seemed to develop
in our lesson? Next time I would like to try this with a class and see if it
makes a difference. I learned that it is really hard for my kids to be
vulnerable with one another at this age- they are really starting to outwardly
judge on another and make more decisions based on the ideas and opinions of
their peers. The part that did work was being able to make that connection-
maybe not for everyone, but there were many who were able to make a connection
with someone else on an answer and seemed genuinely surprised by it- Image if I
did this all the time- would they be more willing to be honest almost from a
truth circle kind of idea, or would it wear off and they would get sick of
doing it this way?